As the Aspen and Roaring Fork school districts grapple with the effects of declining enrollment and state funding losses, they’re also seeing more students cross district boundaries to attend schools, creating competing enrollment pressures for the two neighboring districts.

About 20% of students enrolled in Aspen public schools live outside of the district boundary, west of Gerbazdale Drive off Highway 82 (on the eastern end of Snowmass Canyon), representing approximately 300 students who commute from downvalley. Meanwhile, 10% of Roaring Fork school district students live outside the district, including over 550 students who commute on Interstate 70 from the Colorado River Valley.

Aspen School District for years had restricted enrollment for out-of-district students because of its small class sizes and strong in-district enrollment. But over the past six years, the district has softened these restrictions as birth rates decline, the local population ages and families move away due to the upper valley’s higher cost of living and housing challenges. The Roaring Fork School District — Basalt schools in particular — is seeing the impacts of this policy change as it also grapples with the valley’s demographic shifts and budget challenges tied to state funding, which is based on the number of students enrolled. 

In Colorado’s Northwest region, which extends from Park County to Moffat County, most school districts saw their number of out-of-district students increase from 2015-16. Among those with at least 1,000 students, Aspen School District had in 2025-26 the largest share of out-of-district students relative to its total student population. Meanwhile, Garfield Re-2, encompassing Rifle and Silt, had the largest out-of-district increase in the past decade, with a 122% gain, but the number of students attending from outside the district remains relatively low, at 2% of the student population.

Aspen’s growing out-of-district student population

According to preliminary Oct. 1 counts shared by ASD, 338 pre-K-12 students live outside the district, up from last year’s 315, representing about 22% of the students. Most live in the Basalt area, according to ASD Superintendent Tharyn Mulberry. 

Preliminary data shows that 1,498 K-12 students and 50 preschoolers are attending Aspen schools this year, a total of 1,548 students. This is slightly lower than last school year’s count of 1,553 students, which included 29 preschoolers. 

The Cottage, a preschool staffed by district employees that doesn’t receive state funding and is open to anyone, counts 18 out-of-district students and nearly doubled the number of preschoolers it serves in one year, which, according to Mulberry, is the result of a robust pre-K recruitment effort and increased number of staff members with pre-K-aged children.

In the 2025-26 school year, 20% of ASD students lived outside the district, up from 12% for the 2019-20 school year and from 15% in 2015-16. Meanwhile, the total number of students dropped 6% and 10%, respectively, according to Colorado Department of Education data, which releases official student counts in January.

About 20% of students enrolled in Aspen public schools live outside of the district boundary, west of Gerbazdale Drive off Highway 82 (on the eastern end of Snowmass Canyon), representing approximately 300 students who commute from downvalley. Credit: Laurine Lassalle/Aspen Journalism

Of Aspen’s 315 out-of-district students last school year, 55 were children of teachers and staff, 11 attended The Cottage, and 50 attended Aspen Community School, a K-8 public charter school in Woody Creek that runs its own admission lottery. About 37% of last year’s 134 ACS students lived outside the district.

Each year, the district decides whether to hold a lottery that would allow new out-of-district students to enroll in Aspen schools, based on whether administrators expect to have empty seats in the upcoming school year. Last spring, the district received 60 applications for 75 available spots in Aspen Elementary and Aspen Middle schools. As of Oct. 8, 52 of those applicants are attending ASD. 

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the district changed its policy regarding students who started school in Aspen but later moved downvalley. “The housing issue that occurred during COVID, we had almost 170 students that moved out of Aspen,” Mulberry said. “And we made the decision that it would be very unethical to be throwing them out of school to the other school district just because they had to move because of economic hardship.”

That policy change contributed to the growing share of out-of-district students attending Aspen schools, as did allowing students from Aspen Community School who live outside the district to continue their education at Aspen High School after finishing eighth grade. From the 2015-16 academic year to 2019-20, the school district didn’t allow ACS students to enroll at AHS if they lived outside the district.

Downvalley parents enrolling their children in Aspen is nothing new, and in years when out-of-district enrollment was more restricted, some parents were known to claim residency using an Aspen office address or by other means. In 2011, the district cracked down on students using falsified residency documents, which resulted in at least a dozen students being either kicked out of or prevented from enrolling in the school district. From 2015-16 to 2018-19, the number of students from outside the district dropped by 30%, before increasing by 80% between 2018-19 and 2025-26, to 315 students from 175.

Basalt schools adapting to changes 

Roaring Fork School District spans 14 schools from Basalt to Glenwood Springs. RFSD’s preliminary Oct. 1 enrollment for 2026-27 is estimated at 5,190 K-12 students — down 41 students from the budgeted 5,231 and down 194 students from last year’s K-12 count of 5,384. 

In the past decade, the number of out-of-district students almost doubled, while the total number of students has remained relatively flat. But enrollment changes haven’t affected every school in the district equally. Schools in Carbondale and Glenwood saw enrollment increase by 5% and 8%, respectively, since 2019, while schools in Basalt reported a 20% enrollment decline. 

Basalt’s elementary, middle and high schools have lost a combined 315 students since 2019-20, while enrollment numbers were relatively flat from the 2013-14 through 2019-20 school years. 

RFSD Superintendent Anna Cole said that on top of national trends of lower birth rates, the cost of living has contributed to declining enrollment, especially in Basalt, which is “the highest cost-of-living community that [the district] serve[s].”

Michaela Idhammar, executive director of the Basalt Education Foundation, a nonprofit dedicated to raising money in support of Basalt public schools, said many young families can’t afford to buy or rent in Basalt and end up living farther downvalley or leaving the valley. “That’s a communitywide housing story, and our schools are downstream of it,” she said.

She also acknowledged the draw of Aspen schools. “Many Basalt parents work in Aspen, so an upvalley school can simply fit a family’s daily logistics,” Idhammar said. “Aspen has also actively opened its doors. … So, some of this is Aspen’s business strategy, not a statement about Basalt.”

Basalt Middle School and Basalt High School have seen some of the steepest enrollment declines in the district since 2019. BMS enrollment dropped by 33%, or a loss of 158 students, between 2019 and 2025, and BHS lost 117 students, a 23% drop from 2019.

“Our classes in each grade are smaller and smaller,” BHS Principal Megan Hartmann said. “Families with smaller children are struggling to make the choice to live in Basalt, and I think Basalt is an aging community.”

Basalt’s under-18 population dropped by 5% between 2019 and 2024, while the 65-plus population grew by 32%, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey estimates. In 2024, there were about 1.5 times as many people ages 65 and over in Basalt than children under 18. El Jebel also saw its under-18 population decrease by 35%, while its 65-plus population went up by 11%. 

Basalt’s elementary, middle and high schools have lost a combined 315 students since 2019-20. Although enrollment at Basalt Elementary is slowly declining, the school hasn’t lost as many students as BMS and BHS. Credit: Laurine Lassalle/Aspen Journalism

In response to enrollment declines, which then spur state funding reductions, Hartmann and BMS Principal Jamie Hozack have gotten creative while still trying to offer a full range of subjects for students. 

“Instead of offering both AP Computer Science Principles and AP Computer Science A, we’re now alternating years with those,” said Hartmann, who is also teaching two Advanced Placement calculus classes this year. “As we continue to look at declining enrollment, we’ll probably end up with alternating years on classes in more subject areas.”

Although enrollment at Basalt Elementary is slowly declining, the school hasn’t lost as many students as BMS and BHS. BES has been able to maintain over 500 students — 524 in 2025-26, specifically, a 7% decline from 2019-20’s 564 students.

The dual-language program offered at Basalt Elementary has been a big draw for the school, according to BES Principal Grant Waaler and Assistant Principal Whitney Carper. Both said that the immersion program, which includes daily instruction in both English and Spanish starting in kindergarten, has attracted students from Carbondale, Glenwood Springs and Aspen. 

In 2021, BES’s program went from an optional immersion program that split up students based on their native language to a schoolwide setting where English- and Spanish-speaking students, together, attend classes taught in Spanish for half the day and in English for the other half. This change came after they realized that about 90% of the families wanted the dual-language program and the size of the English-only kindergarten class had dwindled down to six students. “That didn’t make sense for us to run a classroom for six kids,” Waaler said.

Asked about the future of Basalt schools if enrollment continues shrinking, Hozack, Hartmann and Cole said the schools are central to Basalt’s community and they don’t foresee having to take drastic steps such as closing schools anytime soon. 

“[School consolidation] is obviously on our radar,” Cole said, adding that closing a school and grouping students together doesn’t always save money. “I wouldn’t say it’s off the table, but I definitely wouldn’t say it’s on the table. And I would say if it comes on the table, it would only happen after deep conversation with the Basalt community about their hopes and dreams and commitments to our schools.” 

Cole said the schools still have many ways to develop creative partnerships that wouldn’t necessitate closing a school.

Basalt Elementary School second-graders listen to their English-speaking teacher. The dual-language program offered at Basalt Elementary has been a big draw for the school, which includes daily instruction in both English and Spanish starting in kindergarten. Credit: Laurine Lassalle/Aspen Journalism

Mobile communities 

To maintain staffing and its current programming, the Aspen School District doesn’t want to drop below 1,500 K-12 students, according to Mulberry, who recognizes that ASD’s enrollment policies can have implications for RFSD. But with Colorado being an open-enrollment state — meaning that public school students can attend any schools they want if there are spots available, regardless of where they live — he noted that out-of-district enrollment is a common practice across the state and is also used by RFSD.  

“We do not view our enrollment practices as an effort to compete with or diminish RFSD,” Mulberry said. “Our intent has been to fill available seats and maintain sustainable staffing and class sizes, not to systematically increase enrollment at the expense of RFSD.”

In 2025-26, about 10% of RFSD’s pre-K-12 students — specifically, 587 of 5,621 — lived outside the district, up from 6% in 2019-20 and from 5% in 2015-16, when the district had 272 out-of-district students. 

Last year, 10 students who were enrolled in RFSD lived in ASD, but most out-of-district students resided in Garfield Re-2, which extends from New Castle to Rifle. Only 2% of Garfield Re-2 students lived outside the district. 

Cole said the district’s increased number of out-of-district students is most likely due to the valley’s cost of living, which has displaced families to the Colorado River Valley; parents who work in the Roaring Fork Valley and prefer to drop their children off on their way up to work; and the RFSD’s five-day school week (Garfield Re-2 and Garfield 16 have a four-day school week).

RFSD’s out-of-district-student policy is school dependent. If a school receives more applicants than there are spots available, it will run a lottery and use a prioritization system. The district’s charter schools regularly run their own lotteries. Out-of-district students have to be reenrolled each year, which means that if a program is at capacity, out-of-district students are sometimes unable to continue enrollment, although the district strives to keep students whenever possible.

Student-withdrawal data shows that students either move to western Garfield County, to the Front Range, out of state — mostly Texas, Kansas or Idaho — or out of the country. “It’s not one thing. It’s all of them,” Cole said. 

She said that RFSD is exploring an online secondary school associated with Bridges High School in Carbondale, with hopes that it could help bring some kids back to the district, as they have seen an increase in students choosing online school. 

Aspen High Schoolers in French class are among the approximately 1,548 students attending the school district this year, according to preliminary counts — down from 1,727 students in 2015-16. Credit: Laurine Lassalle/Aspen Journalism

School choices stir passions 

For some parents, the decision to send their kids to a school outside of the district where they live comes down to logistics.

Jamie Walbert and his wife live in Carbondale and both work in Aspen. Although they were impressed with Crystal River Elementary in Carbondale, they decided to transfer their son to Aspen Elementary this fall because of the commute. “We often left work around 2:15 to get him, even earlier on early-release days,” Walbert said.

In reporting this story, Aspen Journalism heard from many parents for whom the school choice issue stirs strong passions. 

“It’s really sad to see parents leaving Basalt school district and going up to Aspen, just because I think you lose that sense of community for the families that leave,” said Michelle Kramer Schindler, whose daughter went to Basalt elementary and middle schools and is now a freshman at Basalt High.

Other downvalley parents said that Aspen’s longstanding outdoor education program, funding advantages — referring to millions of additional dollars that benefit Aspen schools each year from private fundraising — and the district’s International Baccalaureate program that shapes curriculum from preschool to 12th grade are the main reasons they chose Aspen schools for their children.

Both school districts have experienced staffing losses over the past three years and have been affected by changes to the state funding formula, which capped the adjustment for cost of living, resulting in reduced funding for schools in high-cost areas. With RFSD voters’ passage earlier this month of a mill levy override, both districts have now passed ballot measures that will help offset some financial losses caused by the formula update and help raise staff salaries, among other financial enhancements.

Laurine Lassalle is Aspen Journalism’s data desk editor, where she works to catalog and analyze local public data. She has a master’s degree in data and investigative journalism from UC Berkeley with...